Add rule [jb]

[2020Vision]

Hello everyone,

So the additional rule that I would like to add is:

Intentional gun plant from terrorist to another terrorist is KOS/Rebelling.

Reason:
I think this should be implemented due to the fact that usually having a gun means you can do 1 of 2 things which is rebel or ask for ST. Some terrorist may not feel confident in there ability to rebel so instead they will pass the gun to another T who is. from there they end up rebelling from a gun that was intentionally passed.

+cons:
allows guards to keep track of T's with guns.
allows higher success chance for Warden.

-cons:
lowers T chance to succesfully rebel.

This is my recommendation Thank you for viewing

 

[Dream__]

+1 but i dont see people pass guns to others, mainly just when asked to throw it away they throw to stack, and thats kos already

 

[Rogue Sniper]

Just tell them not to throw the gun to a teammate and/or throw it to an area where Ts cannot just walk into.

Not a hard concept.

 

[Jacko]

O Orange made this suggestion not to long ago. HERE is the thread if you want to read some arguments for and against this.




TL;DR

The reason we decided not to add something like this is because there are too many situations/gray areas where it would be hard to classify whether or not it would be considered rebelling (e.g. dropping a gun where the warden is taking the Ts)
If the warden wants to say "if you throw a gun into stack you're KOS" then that's up to him.

~Closed

 

[Firesean]

This rule is already within the rules. Throwing contraband is rebelling throwing a gun is rebelling.

 

[2020Vision]

This rule is already within the rules. Throwing contraband is rebelling throwing a gun is rebelling.

yea you see that is what i thought. but today i was told different

 

[Jacko]

This rule is already within the rules. Throwing contraband is rebelling throwing a gun is rebelling.

Throwing any type of grenade or shooting a weapon is considered rebelling. Simply tossing a gun is not considered rebelling, having a rule like that would be pretty troublesome.

At the moment, Warden can specifically order ST's to not assist teammates in rebelling (i.e tossing a gun into stack) or Warden can simply order the ST's to stay away from the general stack of T's as this also prevents confusion from CT's freekilling ST.

Having a rule stating ST's cannot drop a gun to teammates is unusual and specific to add, however, I do agree that this should already be considered rebelling. It's redundant for Warden having to state the obvious "ST's cannot assist teammates in rebellion."

In-direct rebelling (i.e ST intentionally dropping guns to teammates) should be considered rebelling the same way in-direct ghosting (i.e "It's a great day to be at the POOOOOL") is still considered ghosting. I'm pretty sure this fell under common sense back in the day but for some reason or another it fell through the cracks.

Thoughts? ApexLock CtrlAltDelicious

 

[Corrupted]

Throwing any type of grenade or shooting a weapon is considered rebelling. Simply tossing a gun is not considered rebelling, having a rule like that would be pretty troublesome.

At the moment, Warden can specifically order ST's to not assist teammates in rebelling (i.e tossing a gun into stack) or Warden can simply order the ST's to stay away from the general stack of T's as this also prevents confusion from CT's freekilling ST.

Having a rule stating ST's cannot drop a gun to teammates is unusual and specific to add, however, I do agree that this should already be considered rebelling. It's redundant for Warden having to state the obvious "ST's cannot assist teammates in rebellion."

In-direct rebelling (i.e ST intentionally dropping guns to teammates) should be considered rebelling the same way in-direct ghosting (i.e "It's a great day to be at the POOOOOL") is still considered ghosting. I'm pretty sure this fell under common sense back in the day but for some reason or another it fell through the cracks.

Thoughts? Apex Lock CtrlAltDelicious

YoU dIdN't SpElL ApexLock cOrReCtLy

EDIT: NoW yOu DiD.

 

[SneakyTurtle]

Bro just say dont have contra at all lol.

 

[Orange]

O Orange made this suggestion not to long ago. HERE is the thread if you want to read some arguments for and against this.




TL;DR

It was originally going to be a thing in the new rules, but got deleted last minute NotLikeThis

I've gotten used to saying 'don't gunplant/contraplant stack' already.

 

[Mayhem Death]

No need for a rule to be put in for something as small as this. It can easily be stated by the warden that if they pass it along, they are KOS.


Cheers!