lol i just wred this on nerfnow, and i knew it would be here on the forums.
okay, what i think is this:
Demomen, are spammy yes but the spam is SUPPOST to happen. the demoman is suppost to be able to hit you around corners, and if the class did'nt have stickybombs to camp spaces what would be the point of the class? stickies are half the point (half now because of the shield and sword) area denial is what the class was origionally MADE for.
the only reason i think they made the shield and sword instead of new explosion weapons is BECAUSE of this, if there were new explosion weapons, especially denial weapons (discounting the scottish resistance which is hard to use >.>) then we would have people doing this even more then today, that crit grenade is SUPPOST to hurt and the 8 stickies are SUPPOST to kill you, if you have a problem with it remedy it with a spy or a sniper, or hell even an uber if you really need one.
also: sword demos fall before shotguns, shield, while blocking a lot of damage, is easily destroyed.