I already have one. It's called my PM inbox.
I like seeing us explore new ideas for supporting our servers. But this isn't one I see as viable...at least, not with it being practical at the same time.
99% of the clan doesn't get more than a couple PMs per week if I had to bet. Maybe our advisors and above are a little more burdened with division leaders and council members especially receiving them, but even them - I know they're not as burdened with messages as we were when we had so few advisors and such.
What am I going to use an edgegamers.org email address for? Put in on my resume? Yeah ok it can be great to say "I've admined servers", "I've moderated a forum of so many thousand", etc. But in the grand scheme of things, you don't want "edgegamers.org" for any professional use. ...I'm going to assume this wasn't one of the intended uses, though.
If it's just to be one of the cool cats so that you can tell your fellow gamers an edgegamers.org address, well that's all well and good...but paying monthly for it?
I'd go $1 a month if I had use for it, like if I was an advisor or DL or was heavily involved in some inter-eGO programs, but that's the only scenario, and that scenario exists because then it'd be practical.
If it's just to help out the clan..I like helping, but I won't pay $5 for an email address. I already have several that are working fine, and I have my PM inbox for anything else. And if it was $1 a month, I'd rather just donate $15 or $20 every several months as I'm able, which I have (and should be doing again here within the next month or two.)
Not to mention, "subscription" based payment is never good. It makes people feel like they're paying more than they are.
If you told me "$12 for an EdgeGamers.org email address for a year", I'd say "Hey, that's not too bad."
If you told me "$1 a month for an edgegamers email address." I'd say "...what? Why in the hell would I pay monthly for that?"
Maybe that doesn't make sense, but it's the truth. I HATE having "upcoming" payments lingering. Of any amount. Even if it's just a dollar. If I'm going to pay $12 for a year's email, I want to just do it and be able to calculate that and log it away. Not pay month...per month...per month again.
My personal opinion, we've got more important things to consider and think about.