Which of the new motion controlled gaming items/systems is the best in your opinion?

[Artimus]

Thanks to Vexx for this poll question.

 

[shadows5631]

Wii, because it's the original. Xbox and PS3 should have left it alone.

 

[Captn Bean]

Which one shows the most promise? Kinect

 

[!EpIc fAiL!]

The Wii.

 

[RAFIKI]

Wii, because it's the original. Xbox and PS3 should have left it alone.

I 2nd this ^^

 

[Mcore]

I 2nd this ^^

Same

 

[Dayman]

i don't because Microsoft took the wii's idea and made it 100% better than what the wii and PS have done.

 

[Beta]

The Wii made wireless motion control a more casual form of gameplay.
Kinect feels too much like Eyetoy but seems to be getting more attention than the Eyetoy.
PS Move looks like a Wii clone that will support FPS games.

 

[Vexx]

I personally like the Wii, as it's original and led to this new era. But having played the Wii, I found there are a LOT of flaws in it's design. Still a good thing though, esp. since it's a full console, unlike Sony and Microsoft's inventions.

However, I absolutely love Kinect. After watching it numerous times in action, it just looks plain amazing and revolutionary. I can see a lot of potention for gaming with this new style of technology.

So basically... Kinect is in the lead (imo), with Wii just barely behind. As for Move, it's just a bad run-off of the Wii.

 

[Fuzzmunchkin]

I dont think much of Kinect or move for me its wii all the way (when you have black ops for the wii you have a great time)

 

[Naku_vamp]

I say Kenect, the wii is good to it kinda lead the way but it isn't always the original that does it best,

I mean serioly whats better the guy who first found a treatment for cancer? or the guy that actually cure cancer, sure the original lead the way and maybe without his finding the other guy may not have been able to make a cure but point is I think Microsoft took a good thing and made it better.

Quite Frankly the ps3 version looks like they just said "hey lets take what the wii is doing and then copy microsoft coping the wii and then fail at both"

The games for the move look horrible, you have to have a controller AND camera, the controllers look stupid

 

[Donnie the Dinosaur]

Problably kinect because you dont have to hold any magic wand compared to the ps3, and has far superior graphic and game quality compared to the wii.

 

[Donnie the Dinosaur]

Problably kinect because you dont have to hold any magic wand compared to the ps3, and has far superior graphic and game quality compared to the wii.

 

[Donnie the Dinosaur]

Double post fail.

 

[DanJK]

I wouldnt say the Wii is really a "new" system, but its still motion.

Id have to go with Kinect.

 

[KR Decade]

Is there a 'None is good?' Option?? ! :O

 

[Raul Tha Monk]

the 360 is the best!

 

[eurocracy]

Kinect was the winner in a Gadget show review due to it being easy to set up and being incredibly responsive. So I'll go with that one.

 

[Cyberia]

Kinect.

 

[Spitfire'd]

The Wii, because it was first and if it hadn't have done it no one else would have tried it. Sony is even quoted as saying they would never do motion controlled gaming because it was the dumbest idea ever...funny how a few years of sales can change a mind...

Honestly though, motion control is a step backwards for gaming. Instead of taking it and using it to its potential and delivering amazing experiences like it could deliver, companies are now just cashing in on quick and easy mini-games collections. That's right, it's all a gimmick.