- Joined
- Apr 23, 2008
- Messages
- 2,641
Title: Prometheus
Year: 2012
Country of Origin: US
Director: Ridley Scott
Story: A corporate funded expedition is sent to find the origins of man and the answers to some of the most fundamental philosophical questions. But will they like what they find?
Review: So Prometheus is good, not great and most certainly not as genre defining as I had previously hoped. So what went wrong? The best answer is the script. The film tries to delve into philosophical and theological questions like; the nature of faith, who made us and why, and do androids dream of electric sheep? The script isn't smart enough to even begin to explore these questions and the film suffers for bringing them up. Of course we all know why this happened. The film was initially intended to be a straight up prequel to Alien, but mid-production Scott wanted to focus on the philosophy that was present in the script. So a couple of rewrites later we have a script that is not smart discuss philosophy and can't really give any decent scares either.
So what good about the film? First and foremost, its an entertaining film. I was never bored throughout the films run time...which is more than I can say about every Ridley Scott film since Black Hawk Down. The acting a great, with the sole exception of Logan Marshall-Green, who was really miscasted as a scientist. The real star though is Michael Fassbender, as the android David. I am almost entirely certain that without Fassbender, this film would have not been as good as it is now. The direction is pretty good and its technically proficient...I did not see the film in 3D, but it seems like it would have been perfectly fine in 3D.
So the big question; is this a prequel to Alien? Yes, this is a full fledged prequel to Alien, though you do not need to see Alien to enjoy this film...You should still see Alien, like if you get the option to see Alien instead of Prometheus you probably should see Alien. So how does this film stack up? I read on review that equated this movie to 2010, the perfectly watchable sequel to 2001...that just can't quite capture the magic of the first film. I agree with this sentiment, Prometheus is a entertaining film, that is pretty good. It just does not live up to its own potential, and I am not talking about hype here, I am talking about the films potential to reinvigorate the hard Sci-fi genre.
[7/10]













)