To be honest, I was kinda skeptical about it before actually playing it. I'm a gigantic ST geek, so my opinion of the game is biased because of that, but I was pleasantly surprised from what I've played.
THIS. THIS RIGHT HERE.
I've talked to a lot of Trekkies about this game, and what I get back is all the same: daww, the graphics look lame, and anyway I've never played a Star Trek game I like and, ewww, it takes place after Nemesis? They then pull a preconception out of their butt and quote it for truth, and smugly confirm for themselves tha the game sucks without taking a moment to even try it.
I blame Cryptic a bit for being... Cryptic. There's a ton of screenshots, all shot at, what looks like Minimum settings. And their site has a bare minimum of background information about the game, which is sad, as they seem to have built a pretty complex backstory about what has happened between Nemesis and "now" in the game. Which leads casual people to give casual effort into looking into the game.
Then, I lambast the trekkie. I make them feel bad. If necessary, I mention how their heresy must be making Gene Roddenberry spin in his grave. And once they get in, I get:
1) Wow, it's buggy but it's beta. I won't be paying for it but they lavished a lot of love on the storyline. I'm surprised, it's pretty good.
2) Wow, now that was fun! I'm so gonna buy this! X, Y, and Z are great!
So for all you haters out there... try it. Maybe wait a week for the majority of patches to come out, then give it a try... it costs you nothing but a bit of bandwidth to try it with a free beta key.
I, too, once did the same thing with Star Trek: Enterprise. After watching the first 3 episodes, I decided that the writers were going out of their way to destroy Star Trek and actively campaigned against the show. Years later a friend of mine guilted me into giving later episodes a look-see, and while Enterprise is still my least favorite Star Trek TV Series, I have more respect for it. It happens every day
