Title: Lucy
Year: 2014
Country of Origin: France/US
Director: Luc Besson
Plot: Scarlett Johansson plays Lucy, an American student studying in Taiwan. After a run in with a Korean (?) mob boss she is forced to become a drug mule carrying a new an experimental smart drug. Things get really dumb after the container carrying this drug is ruptured and she gets dosed by the contents.
Review: There is a famous line from the film
Tropic Thunder; "Never go full retard." I would explain the context of this quote, but honestly
Tropic Thunder is eight or so years old at this point you've probably should have seen it by now. Anyway, I bring this up because there is a similar rule should be taken into account for action movies; never go all powerful. One of the main things that makes action cinema fun and compelling is there there are stakes; stop the bad guy, save someone, get revenge, or any number of things. Without stakes, then there is no tension and without tension you cannot make a compelling action film. If the main character fails, then bad things will happen. When a main character becomes all powerful though, it robs the plot of its stakes and tension. You need there to be a reasonable assumption of failure. Imagine Superman if he only dealt with street crime, that is not an interesting story. For every Goku, you need a Frieza. Otherwise, there is simply no reason to tell a story.
By the final third of
Lucy, the film strips out all of the tension because she has become all powerful; think Dr. Manhattan or Tetsuo from
Akira. We lose all reasonable expectation of failure because she can now stop anyone by simply thinking about it. So, in this aspect the film fails as an action movie.
Lucy though is not you're basic action movie, it wants to explore metaphysics...specifically man's perception of the world. See, this film employs the debunked theory that we only use 10% of our brain as a plot device to explain the evolutionary steps of our main character. As the plot moves forward Lucy unlocks more and more of her brain and her perception of the world begins to change. It's about as dumb as you would expect it to be, though arguably there are some nifty ideas floating around this film.
Breaking away from plot mechanics, the film's production is on par with other Besson films. It looks nice and the overall production design is solid. Scarlett Johansson does a good job with what she is given, even though by the end of the film her character essentially becomes emotionless and wooden...think Arnold in the first
Terminator. The rest of the cast doesn't have a whole lot to do since their character's mostly just stand around aghast at the powers that Lucy displays. Now that I think about it the only interesting character in the film is the aforementioned Korean mob boss who is out to kill Lucy at all cost. Honestly, I kind of wanted to see him succeed since he was the only one who had any real motivation. Seriously, Lucy's motivations and actions became obtuse and hazy by the second half of the film.
I actually want to contrast this with
Limitless, a film with a similar plot minus the action and metaphysics. See, with
Limitless we have Bradley Cooper as our narrator and we get to know what's going on and how the character is reacting to the changes that he is going through. On top of this, the changes are not permanent so he has to keep dosing on the smart drug in order to maintain it's effects. While, I thought
Limitless was 'good but not great' it is miles ahead of Lucy because it understands what an audience needs in order to get into a story. If there are no stakes or the audiences loses protagonist's motivations, then you have a dumb and ultimately dull film.
[4/10]