Title: Sucker Punch
Year: 2011
Country of Origin: US
Director: Zack Snyder
Story:Is Zack Snyder's (
Dawn of the Dead (2004),
300,
Watchmen) first original story an amazing tour de force or a crushing disappointment?
Review: I like Zach Snyder, the man knows what is awesome and since Dawn of the Dead he has been my go to guy for competently directed action films. So at the prospects of getting an original story from him is an exciting one. When I first saw the trailer for Sucker Punch I didn't know how to react, it seemed the Snyder threw everything but the kitchen sink of geek fodder in to one film. There was Steam Punk, D&D, and sci-fi...not to mention constant bombardment of '40 Pin-up imagery. It looked to be that Snyder was going for broke with this film and I was more than willing to pay to see the final product. The only thing that had me worried though was whether or not Snyder could create a narrative structure to fit all these elements into a single film?
It saddens me to report that Snyder could not come up with a good enough narrative structure and as such the film suffers. It's a film that is essentially about a group of girls attempting to escape an insane asylum before a doctor arrives to lobotomize our protagonist. The story then switches to a fantasy world where the girls are attempting to escape a brothel...and sometime to the story switches to an even further fantasy where they're fighting undead Germans or dragons. The actual plot is told through Lynchonian dream logic...meaning that what is happening in the fantasy worlds is a metaphor for what is happening in reality. So when I say they're escaping from the fantasy brothel what I mean is that they're escaping the asylum. Now in theory this narrative structure should be more than enough to all the various elements together, but it doesn't.
The "dream logic" plot mechanic actually works to disjoint the film which breaks it's pacing and narrative flow. This unfortunately pull the audience out of the experience. To make matters worse, the plot device that use to switch to the battle scenes is really clunky. In fact my friend leaned over to me during one of these transitions and said "this is really stupid". I actually tried to defend it, but I couldn't think of a single thing to say in the device's defense. It gets even worse when you get to the characters, which are unfortunately cardboard and shallow. All of the the protagonists, saved for a sage like old man, are are female...and all the antagonists are male. I mean Snyder set up what could have been his Kill Bill or even something greater and more subversive. But Snyder doesn't capitalize off this other than some T&A.
As far as the action goes, it's alright. Snyder once again over utilizes his patented "stop & go" high kinetic slow-mo. I mean I like Snyder's use of slow-mo and all, but it's over used just like in his earlier films. The action is fun but outlandish and removed from the story making it seemed tacked on for no real reason. Of course that's the biggest issue with the whole film, everything feels unnecessary. The characters, the plot, the action, the settings, the cinematography, the sound track...it just feels tacked on with no real connection to one another. I wanted to like this film, I really did. I saw the critical consensus on Rottentomatoes and thought "screw the critics, I'm going to see this film and I'm going to like it." But alas, I cannot recommend this film to anyone.
[4/10]