Looking for Criticism

[BokkChoi]

Well, I've seen a lot of different threads like this one will be, all I am looking for is criticism harsh or nice for my sigs, I feel like I am rapidly gaining skill in making sigs. I will add every Sig I make to this thread, and hopefully people will help me out. I will go from what I see as my worst, to my best sigs. Here goes nothing.

#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6

#7

#8

#9

#10

#11

#12

So yeah, I'm just looking for some criticism, and maybe some hints and or tips.

Thanks in Advance!

 

[reflex99]

Alot of them have empty space, maybe fill with a background or something?

 

[BokkChoi]

I didn't know what to do with any of those. It's before I learned the arts properly :S

 

[TremendousLion]

I like 10 and 7 but they do have a lot of empty space. I would suggest some C4Ds or effects, or an interesting background. 11 is beautiful, and by far my favorite

 

[BokkChoi]

Yeah, the ones with the huge white spaces are probably my least favorite. I didn't know what to do with the whole other half of the Sig so I just decided to go with it. I'm starting to look away from all the smudging that made those sigs and am trying to make busier sigs.

 

[3sev3n]

yea 10 is the best but needs some back ground Filler keep up the good work tho

 

[PloxBox]

11 and 12 look like your best ones, since they have the less open space, other then that, you're doing really good, alot better then i could! xD

 

[BokkChoi]

Hah, thanks guys

 

[MoSTaR #GH]

#'s 7 and 10-12 look the best to me, and the others look like simple photoshopping work.

 

[BokkChoi]

#'s 7 and 10-12 look the best to me, and the others look like simple photoshopping work.

Well the thing is, they were. haha.

 

[BokkChoi]

New favorite. What do you guys think?