Here are the maps I see in the 5 cp rotation:
Obvious ones, IMO:
Gravelpit
Dustbowl
Questionable:
Badlands
Well
Fastlane
Warpath
Steel
Granary
I think it should be:
Gravelpit
Dustbowl
Granary
Fastlane
Well
No crits/No spread 24 slots.
On the other hand, there could also be a valvemaps + convoy server.
Composure: 2 ctf, 3 cp, 3 arena + Convoy.
I like this idea because I do believe degrootkeep may be getting dropped, so we will already have a pl server. This satisfies everyone's wants for cp, ctf, arena, and convoy. And I think that this should also be 24 slots no crits/no spread.
My Setup:
Ctf Maps:
Convoy is included seperately
Turbine
Double Cross
CP Maps:
Dustbowl
Gravelpit
Fastlane
Arena Maps:
Lumberyard
Offblast
Badlands
No crits/No spread 24 slots.
Now my third and fourth options could abduct a HUGE following.
Number three is, as mentioned before, a funmaps server. The lack of good funmaps servers on TF2 is astounding, and when people see a good prophunt server go up, they jump on it.
Number four is TF2 Zombiemod. Zf (Zombie Fortress) is a gamemode not that explored in TF2 by many clans, and the servers are generally full. Grabbing a Zf server could bring in a lot of new recruits and a huge pub fanbase allowing us to expand as a whole.
If you look at these four options, #s 1 and 2 bring in competitive players and, possibly, make us a more competitive clan.
#s 3 and 4 bring in a lot of pubs and potential recruits.
It all depends on what we are most concerned about. People complain about two 2fort servers, but they are constantly full; also, I get the most recruits on the 2forts easily. If we are most concerned about recruiting, Mesa has the lowest recruit rate, so should we get rid of it? Well, of course not, it is the highest ranked server. So if server rankings are everything, should we be getting rid of our lowest ranked servers even if we pull in lots of recruits and haven't had a chance to grow yet?
As you can see, it is all very confusing. For those of you who did a TL;DR...
TL;DR
1. Cp Rotation (5 maps) No Crits/No Spread 24 slots
Gravelpit
Dustbowl
Granary
Fastlane
Well
2. Valvemaps (and convoy) (9 maps) No Crits/No Spread 24 slots
Ctf Maps:
Convoy
Turbine
Double Cross
CP Maps:
Dustbowl
Gravelpit
Fastlane
Arena Maps:
Lumberyard
Offblast
Badlands
3. Fun Maps (24 slots?)
Optional things:
Wacky Races
Prophunt
Pyro Tennis
Saxton Hale
Randomizer
(Suggestions for other mods appreciated!)
4. Zombie Mod (As many slots as we can handle!)
Good Zf maps, and our mappers can make some, too!
Those are the basic suggestions I have, modify them as you wish!