Btw, when you say to keep it cheap, what does that mean exactly? Everyone has their own preference on what "cheap" is. Do you want to be in the same range as your previous Razer or do you want to go cheaper?
Logitech G5..... I've had it for around 7 years now. Just got the newer version (G500) of it a year ago, but not because it was broken or anything. It's a very simple mouse and well built for a fair price