Call of Duty Modern Warfare 4 Review

1000039485.png


Call of Duty Modern Warfare 4 Game Overview
Is it as bad a recent releases, just another COD, or one of the best campaigns in the franchise?​

Let me start by saying this: to quote the great warrior poet, Taylor Swift: "Hi. I'm the problem. It's me."

One of the main complaints against the CoD franchise is that it is so watered down by yearly releases. However, I'm the guy that comes back year after year after year for this series. I love Call of Duty. I love Call of Duty campaigns. Of course, I also enjoy the multiplayer (usually), but I am a campaign guy through and through. All combined, I've undoubtedly spent more time in various CoD games than any other franchise dating all the way back to the original in 2003. However, in recent years it has been... well... let's just say it has been difficult to love this franchise.

2019 was a high point in the franchise in both critical acclaim and sales success that had not been seen since the golden era of the 2010s. Just 1 year removed from Black Ops 4 having absolutely no campaign whatsoever, Modern Warfare (2019) was a much needed breath of fresh air in the franchise and is one of the most successful video games of all time. Since then, Call of Duty has struggled to reach that peak again and, at times, has fallen completely off the mountain altogether in spectacular style.

Black Ops 6 and Cold War were just ok, Vanguard was a solid "meh", and Modern Warfare 2 had GREAT characters with maddening gameplay mechanics. And then there was Modern Warfare 3 and Black Ops 7: I don't think I'm being overly hyperbolic when I say these are objectively two of the worst video games ever made. Modern Warfare 3 was mostly recycled open-world Warzone maps and Black Ops 7 was what would happen if you asked ChatGPT to make a Call of Duty game.

So, the big question: does Modern Warfare 4 continue the free fall or is it a return to form?

CAMPAIGN​

I'll be upfront with this to avoid clickbait and then I'll explain a little: this is one of my favorite CoD campaigns ever. For sure in the top 5 and a case could be made for top 3.

As far as the overall narrative, from the very first mission this campaign does something rare in the reboot Modern Warfare timeline. In the previous 3 games, you predominately play as some legendary super soldiers. Tier 1 SAS operatives like Price, Gaz, Soap, or Ghost. CIA Ground Branch operator Alex Keller. Charismatic resistance leader Farah Karim. All larger than life characters in their own ways.

But in this game? You spend most of the time with 2 characters: a rogue Captain Price on the run after the events of MW3 and Park Hyun-Jun, a South Korean Marine Private. Very early in the first mission there is a line of dialogue that can be taken as just simple character exposition via comic relief. But I think this one line sets the tone for the whole campaign. After one of your American squad mates tries to impress a local South Korean girl with his "attempt" at speaking Korean, his squad mates say: "Service is mandatory for us, Dunn. You're not special to them."

For the majority of this game, you are just a regular guy thrown into an extreme situation being asked to do extraordinary things. Even for the levels where you play as Price, you are no longer a SAS operator equipped with the latest and greatest. Some of the Price missions you don't even have a weapon. As spectacular and bombastic as this campaign gets, at times it can still feel surprisingly grounded.

At the end of the day, this is a CoD game. You're not here for high-brow thought-provoking content. You didn't come for a Christopher Nolan brain-exploding movie, you're here for a Michael Bay "ooooooooooh look at the pretty explosions" blockbuster experience. MW4 delivers on that exceptionally well. Call of Duty is the McDonald's of the gaming world. It's not the best food, but man, sometimes you just want a quarter pounder. That's Modern Warfare 4 in a nutshell.

Without spoilers, the one whiplash I had with the story is the introduction of Mads Mikkelsen as the new big bad guy. Even from the trailers, this character just screamed "hey, we know we screwed up the Makarov character in the last two games so here's Mads Mikkelsen". With that being said, you very quickly do not care about this because it's Mads freakin' Mikkelsen. The developers handed you an olive branch as a way to say sorry and it's really really good so you very quickly don't care and catch yourself thinking "Makarov who?"

The gameplay is where I was the most worried. Modern Warfare 2 and 3 introduced some questionable mechanics like increasingly armored enemies and open-world levels using reused Warzone maps. Thankfully, both these features are refined and much more enjoyable.

MW4 has armored enemies, but it works in a much better way. Where MW2 and 3 enemies were just bullet sponges with increasingly thicker armor that you had to break, MW4 armored enemies take much less fire and can be taken down with 1 shot in the right place. Overall, this game rewards accuracy and semi-auto fire over the full-auto mag dumping in previous games. Heavily armored juggernauts are still a thing but are much more sporadic. I can only think of 4 or 5 off the top of my head total in the entire MW4 campaign.

As far as the open-world levels, there is only one in MW4 and, thankfully, it's not just a recycled Warzone map. You can play it quick with fast travel options or you can explore the narratively rich map. There are story and gameplay perks if you explore it.

My one big complaint with the campaign is that it is a little on the short side with only 16 missions and ends kind of abruptly. When the credits rolled, I had a "wait... that's it?" reaction.

There are also some moments that just feel silly. As a realism nerd, using armor plates as a consumable resource just had me giggling at times. Also, and this is not a spoiler because it's in the trailer, there's the big showdown between Ghost and Price. Ghost gets slashed and stabbed with a knife no less than 20 times and the extent of that damage is he shows up in the next cutscene with a bandage on his forearm.

The game also introduces a new fist-fighting mechanic. The first level that it's used is really fun, a night club fight that was obviously inspired by John Wick. However, that mechanic gets pretty old fairly quick.

MULTIPLAYER​

I'll lightly touch on the multiplayer because, to be totally honest, if you've played any Call of Duty multiplayer you either love it or you hate it. If you have played a CoD game online in the last 5-10 years, then there is nothing radically different here. It can be as fun as it is frustrating at times. I've got 3 or 4 hours playing Hardcore TDM and Kill Confirmed and, yeah, it's a CoD multiplayer experience.

I'll share some good, the bad, and the ugly:

The good: I really like "realistic" guns and skins in my CoD games. Modern Warfare 2019 was really good at balancing the "milsim" elements with the bonkers crazy. MW2 and 3 kind of lost that and leaned way more into the bonkers. Modern Warfare 4 balances the 2 fairly well.

The bad: This may be an "old man yells at clouds" moment of this review, but good grief, the multiplayer menu is just too much. Every time I open multiplayer I feel like The Simpsons watching Japanese cartoons.

The ugly: Skill-based matchmaking is absolutely infuriating and is the worst part of all modern Call of Duty games. This is a well-documented gripe since SBMM was introduced and isn't going away anytime soon, but still needs to be said: SBMM is awful.

FINAL THOUGHTS
​
If you like Call of Duty games, especially Modern Warfare 2019, then you'll love this game and I highly recommend it. If CoD isn't your thing, this isn't reinventing the wheel in any way and you'll probably want to avoid this.

The campaign is a lot of fun but is a little on the short side. The multiplayer is nothing new, but that doesn't mean bad at all. The worst part of CoD multiplayer, SBMM, remains and seriously impacts the experience.

-RATING-
⭐⭐⭐⭐

(out of 5)​



POST CREDITS
Writing: masterofpuppets masterofpuppets | Graphics: masterofpuppets masterofpuppets | Contributor: @LukePyro

Check EdgeGamers out on Social Media:
TikTok | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram |
YouTube​
 
mid warfare 4
And then there was Modern Warfare 3 and Black Ops 7: I don't think I'm being overly hyperbolic when I say these are objectively two of the worst video games ever made.
Fire this writer mwiii is one of the few good recent cods outside of zombies
bo7 is arguable bcuz of being 99% AI but zombies still decent
 
Last edited:
mid warfare 4

Fire this writer mwiii is one of the few good recent cods outside of zombies
bo7 is arguable bcuz of being 99% AI but zombies still decent
MW3 is awful. Boring open world warzone maps, re-used MW2 plot points (another false flag), reboot Makarov is a terrible antagonist. There's literally nothing redeemable in that campaign.
 
MW3 is awful. Boring open world warzone maps, re-used MW2 plot points (another false flag), reboot Makarov is a terrible antagonist. There's literally nothing redeemable in that campaign.
only the campaign was bad the multiplayer was amazing with tons of live support and updates using og maps. events were peak too with W camos. warzone zombies was interesting and fun to grind. everything was just a better mwii not including campaign. warzone maps were good and rebirth actually felt like rebirth
 
Back
Top