fudpeX's Fallout3 Review

fudpeX

Forum Fiend
Joined
Jul 21, 2009
Messages
746
(copied Prototypes Review)

My review of fallout 3. And this is not accurate to the average gamer. So don't take my reviews word on your decision to buy the game. read prototypes. HERE

When i read about what Bethesda said about the game before it was released i got scared and this is a direct quote.
This is going to be a tough one, die-hard fallout fans are either going to love it, or hate it.
..i hated it

When i first was thinking about buying the game i was a little edgy because i played Fallout 1, 2, and Tactics and thought they were making a huge mistake for letting Bethesda use their Oblivion's Engine and revamping what was already a flawless game. The original fallout's had amazing story lines and open ended "choose your own path/character" as does F3. but Fallout 3 lacked on many aspects that the originals did not.

Graphics 6/10

The graphics are OK. Bethesdas Engine is always good. The looks were impressive, but they weren't exciting. They went to far on "Post-Apocalyptic" and looking at rubble, rocks, and dead trees got old very fast. After about 2 hours into the game, i was dieing to get a quest that took me into a dungeon or warehouse so i could stop looking at the boring environment almost the entire game has. And the guns? they were way to boxy and unrealistic. and the textures on them where stretched.

fallout-3-review.jpg

*YAWN*



Story 5/10

The story was good, but not the best from the franchise. predictable, yes from someone like me who's played the others. And i felt like the side quests didn't do anything for the story at all, the only thing that changed the story was the Karma system. I'm not going to tell you why i thought this for that would be a spoiler. They say there are over 300 endings to the game. Thats retarded, there's only 2 endings. and again i cant tell you why thats a "FACT" or it will be a spoiler.

Gameplay 7/10

The gameplay was unique, that's for sure. I tried to utilize the V.A.T.S system as much as i could because I loved the turn based system that Fallout was known for. Fallout to me was amazing because you could choose the outcome of any battle primarily on your choice of action during a battle. This is why they created the V.A.T.S. system. Which i hope is used in future games. but sometimes the vats system was just unnecessary, which pissed me off because it lead me to playing it like every other FPS. I'm fine with that because i am a FPS Player. But conserving ammo and taking strategic shots are what the games supposed to be about. And if you run through the game never using the V.A.T.S. system then theres no reason to boost your Action Points is there? and Fallout is known for its Action Points. People thought about Action points before Health Points and Armor Classes. When you have played all the "Elder Scrolls" as well, it defiantly ruined the entire game for me because Fallout 3 felt too similar. The control was not mastered for an FPS. Bethesda hasn't realized that in an FPS, the forward and back acceleration speed is not the same speed as movement left and right. "go ahead test that out on ANY OTHER FPS GAME." Its like how the makers of "Gears of War" did Unreal Tournament 3, and completely ruined that franchise.

AI 3/10

The AI in this game was god awful. First of all, when any enemy was low on health they ran away and made it way to easy to kill them. Any enemy when exploring woul do nothing but just run straight toward you and start shooting. The only AI i saw impressive were the ones during the cut scenes.

*This Wasn't In Prototypes*

MUSIC 1/10

The only music that fit the theme was during a battle. and hopefully you hit a random good one during a dungeon quest. But when i was exploring, the music *and i blame Bethesda* was to identical to Oblivion. Most of the exploring music had harps, and flutes. HARPS AND FLUTES? IN A POST APOCALYPTIC GAME?! I'm sorry but Fallout is supposed to be a Mature Rated game. They tried, buy putting in hanging bodies and using the F word a couple of times. But in the other games, the world was a lot more violent, and a lot more gore and evil. So the music needs to fit the scene.

Overall: 5/10 *and thats being nice because i love fallout.*

Overall my opinion was that it was a failure and after playing the game all the way threw, side quests and all, then playing it again to take a different route. I uninstalled, and installed Fallout 2.

The only reason why Bethesda took over the franchise is because Bethesda "other than Obsidian Who Should have done it" are good with open ended games that are properly funded. And Bethesda took it because they have fallout fans in their Staff.

Fallout 3 didnt even have most of the enemies and tribes from the others. i dont even think Fallout3 HAD tribes. which were a big influence. There were a lot of things that went introduced which should have. Crippling an enemy showed no effect on their abilities to fight. so crippiling a leg is pointless. whereas in the others, crippling a leg is pretty much all you want to do because you dont want to kill the person. and as for shooting someone in the face and blinding them? again im sure F3 didnt even have that, and crippiling the arms showed no effect on their ability to shoot worse. so why the hell would you aim for the arms? They actually created a "MOD" for the game that integrated this feature. because Bethesda are morons. "Action Points" almost mean nothing in Fallout 3 because once you run out, you can just go ahead and shoot freely like any other game. Fallout was a game where you used up all your action points available and then it was the next persons turn. Equiping another gun would use action points, changing the type of fire would be an action point, movin was an action point, and reloading and or fleeing would be one too. Like Final Fantasy almost, but in its own unique way. That's like turning the New Final Fantasy into an FPS. It just wouldn't be final fantasy anymore. Might as well call it Final Fantasy Carnage. Might as well call fallout 3, "FALLOUT VENGEANCE." I think the game was RUSHED and did not reach my expectations as a fallout game.
 
Last edited:
you'd better hide before Carmine sees this :O:O

just joking!

Ok, so I gather you didn't like it; to be honest, the fist part (inside the vault) I was't totally impressed myself. I didn't hate that part, I just wasn't feeling the total immersion being described to me by others, and certainly not feeling the need to gush about the game like so many people were doing; however, once I reached the outside, mucked around in Megaton, and consequently blew it up from the safety of Tenpenny Towers (yes I blew it up!) I was totally hooked. This game, to me anyway, is up there with the greats, something I may pull down and replay again and again and still enjoy it.

That's just me though; everyone gets tickled in a different way, right?
 
Read a real review before you decide on this game.
 
I enjoyed fallout myself but really I was expecting an oblivion with guns. And I was majorly let down by the fact that on PC the VATS system crashed my game half the time I used it. Overall not as good as oblivion, but then again few things are.
 
I never used VATS. I hate turn based games. I want to play it, not watch my char do something, wait, let the enemy do something, ect. I didn't care for the weapon damage too much, I hated watching enemies take multiple headshots. I played Fallout 2 for a little bit, storyline was good, gameplay was a failure. After I missed a scorpion that WAS RIGHT IN MY FACE for the 5th time in a row, I just turned it off. I admit the movement is a bit wonky as an FPS, and the game does get boring after awhile. I downloaded FOOK and Mart's mutant mod, and it made it worth playing regularly. FOOK adds 120 new guns, and the damage is better. The mutant mod increases enemy spawns by 3-5x. Now I am getting in firefights with 10-15 mutants at a time. The game does require some tweaking, but it is decent. I had to custom make a char to make the game interesting for me. My char was a ninja, I lowered carry weight to 60, boosted my H2H dmg to 200, ect. There are so many enemies at lvl 20, having 800 HP, and 200 H2H damage is making things even. Overall, the game did have flaws and problems, but it was good for what it was. I enjoyed sneaking through sewers shooting ghouls in the head with hunting rifles. What I loved in Oblivion was when I pulled off 1 shot kills with the bow. It mostly did this in Fallout 3.

I played Fallout 3 a lot, and still do sometimes, so I thought I would add this in. If you don't like the way the game is now, there are hundreds of mods to suit you.
 
Last edited:
Sorry dude, but I just can't accept this as a viable review. It sounds like you shouldn't have even been playing it. You wanted something other than post-apocalyptic, like warehouses and dungeons, well you probably should've picked a different game. I think they did a great job converting the landscape to a post-apocalyptic look. As far as the weapons being too boxy, well thats just personal taste. And I hate to tell you, but many of them aren't.

It sounds to me that you just didn't get what you expected, or wanted, therefore it was bad.
 
This game was amazing but after I beat the main story line, I kinda got bored and sold the game. I prefer Oblivion, what made me mad was that Fallout 3 had no guilds in the game. I liked Oblivion because of their variety of guilds. Fallout 3 overall was a decent game.
 
This is Carmine. Your review makes Carmine cry.
^^

Yeah.. sounds like another "It's not fallout 1 or 2 so i'm not going to like it" fan. What do you expect from a post-apocolyptic wasteland other than dirt and rocks...? If you want more scenery there are like 5 mods that add in grass, trees, takes of the green tint etc etc. The guns don't look boxy at all, im running at max settings and they are really detailed. This game is amazing..
 
Last edited:
I played Fallout 3 for 10hours then I uninstalled, took it back in the package and returned it to the store saying that the cd was ruined when i opened it or something like that. Such producers won't get my money! :)
 
like i posted fellas. My review is not for the average gamer. and not to take my review for advice. It's just my opinion on the game. Yes i can describe it a lot better in person the flaws as played. and post-apocalyptic is what i wanted, no i didn't want grass and trees. The point was that there could have been more than vast areas of nothing. As noted in red writing, "dont take my advice on the game, read prototypes" I just wanted to vent my frustration about the game ;). Although Bethesda will defiantly rectify my loss with fallout with their new game comming out which is co-produced by Splash Damage. "BRINK". Cant wait. ;)
 
I liked the game but i have to agree with you, fudpeX. It did feel rushed and the bugs/crashes didn't make it any better. Wish they took some more time into it. Still i found it an OK game.
 
I thought it was done very well, i was expecting post apocalytic and i personally wasn't disappointed. there were some cool side stories and little pockets of adventures around the map. i enjoyed it and would be playing currently except the game crashes on me so oh well.
 
Read a real review before you decide on this game.

I got this game a few months ago after reading a so called "real review" and thought FO3 was over rated, i found it to be poorly made, everything just felt fake and cheap,i could not get emersed into the story and the world of FO3

ps: i love rpg games and can play them for hundreds of hours if they are good.
 
I played Fallout 3 for 10hours then I uninstalled, took it back in the package and returned it to the store saying that the cd was ruined when i opened it or something like that. Such producers won't get my money! :)

And it worked?! Wow, I have to try that sometimes :D
 
And it worked?! Wow, I have to try that sometimes :D

Note to all. PC Games are not allowed to be returned for piracy issues. So if you want to return a PC game, keep this in mind. This can also be used for any Shrink Wrap Product.

Purchase a good box cutter and a lighter.

Carefully cut the packaging where its thick "the line on every shrink wrap product" and open the packaging very carefully, may take longer but useful for this reason.

When returning the product, place the packaging back into the shrink wrap and use the lighter to burn the line back in place.

;) Like it was never opened. :D

but please god don't pirate cd's and do that. Or i will find you and arrest you myself. ;)
 
Sure the game had drawbacks, but like you, I have been playing FPS games since Wolf3D. They should have had better pistol damage for one, and I have never been a fan of hard settings that do nothing besides make the enemy harder to kill, make more enemies or something. Nothing kills immersion like watching an enemy take several rifle headshots.
 
Note to all. PC Games are not allowed to be returned for piracy issues. So if you want to return a PC game, keep this in mind. This can also be used for any Shrink Wrap Product.

Purchase a good box cutter and a lighter.

Carefully cut the packaging where its thick "the line on every shrink wrap product" and open the packaging very carefully, may take longer but useful for this reason.

When returning the product, place the packaging back into the shrink wrap and use the lighter to burn the line back in place.

;) Like it was never opened. :D

but please god don't pirate cd's and do that. Or i will find you and arrest you myself. ;)

Wow, that's professional talk right there. Thanks!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top