Which of the new motion controlled gaming items/systems is the best in your opinion?

[[HoneyChicken]]

Move. Reason being, it's MUCH more responsive than any of the other 2 that I have played, and just needs some key titles to come out. The Wii, you could just sit down and play, which was not its aim but it became to be like that. Kinect is unresponsive, but the idea of it is fantastic. The other 2 are very good, but Move is the best.

 

[Carmine]

Where is the none option?

 

[Darth]

Ive only played on the Wii, so the Wii

 

[The Slayer]

xbox is crap, wii is crap, ps3 ftw (if it wouldn't give a yellow screen or w/e it's called )

 

[Coal Felpz]

How could you say that Microsoft took Nintendos idea? They are totally different! One needs a stupid white brick to move the people and one doesn't. I don't understand how some people say these are the same. The only similarity, and correct me if I am wrong, is that they are both motion controlled. With Kinect being much more "Controllable" and those Wii controllers screw up all the time.

 

[Desmolizer]

Kinect!

 

[Dr.Compton]

Wii, because it's the original. Xbox and PS3 should have left it alone.

Thats like saying there shouldnt be a CS:S because 1.6 is original, Valve should have left it alone.

The kinect is almost completely differnt, the other two still require a controller of some sort. The kinect just requires you. The kinect is amazing.

 

[Dutchoper72]

wii reason is because everything else is a knock off of it

 

[ans]

wii, ofc.....

 

[P3N]

Even when I'm not a console players... I must say the MS Kinect will change everybody's world not because of MS, the people is creating tons of apps for it really good! so... this "console" toy will be soon in our PC's ^^

 

[JimMusty]

Wii, because it's the original. Xbox and PS3 should have left it alone.

Maybe, but PS3 did it better than Wii, and Xbox did it better than PS3

 

[Cut Chem!st]

Motion controls are harming games, just increases the amount of shovelware.

 

[SingularPoint]

I judge a console by it's library and neither the Move or Kinect has interested me. No developer has shown interest in developing on the Kinect with tittles I care about, so I have no interest in it.
But I have had the Wii since it's launch 2 years ago so it's not "new" to me either and no third party developer has any interest in it now. The Move shows the most promise with both first and third parties supporting it heavily

 

[Death Injection]

Personally I love the Kinect, it's amazing in every way.

The Wii is cool too, but it just doesn't have the gameplay I like.

The PS3 Move's controllers look a bit... you know. Weird. I mean it's a nunchuck and a wii-mote with a giant ball on the end. WTF?

 

[Mr.President]

Playstation move has different colors... beat that kinect

 

[Gear]

The Wii. The Wii is original, XBOX and PS have taken the idea from Nintendo. They shouldn't have gone into the Motion games.

 

[Toxxin]

Which one shows the most promise? Kinect

^^This

 

[Silent Ghost]

i just say Xbox!

 

[Master Gunns]

The PS3 move is best imo.

It's a HD Wii with 1:1 tracking and basically 0 delay. Sure the Wii came first, but it's all kids/party games. With the PS3 Move you will be able to play actual games/FPS.

The Kinect is basically the Wii without remotes. But imo to play the games I like, you need a controller.

Take The Fight: Lights Out vs the Kinect fighting game. The Fight, your guys does what you do 1:1. You have to punch like you mean it, block, etc. Whereas with the Kinect you basically perform an action (like hitting a button) which then prompts a pre rendered move. IE you lift your knee to preform a knee strike.

 

[OfficerHotpants]

The Kinect most definitely... It's great for parties or small get-togethers..

The move is basically the Wii.. except with glowing colored balls on the remote! (OOOooooohhhh!!! exciting! Innovation!) rofl.. but yea..

Most people say that to play good games you need some sort of controller device.. but the kinect is so accurate (if you set it up correctly) that this shouldnt be a problem..