1)5 years too late to the HD scene.
2)Awkward pointless new controller
3)No new imaginative titles still riding the Mario/Zelda/Metroid franchises into the ground.
4)Games for hardcore players are already out on other systems or being brought over. Nothing new or imaginative.
5)Battery life for 3DS sucks
6)Starfox game is a remake instead of a new title and its only on handheld.
7)Still no answer for the PSN or Live
1) Who cares? There have been great gorgeous games on the Wii that I certainly have enjoyed. I still play NES games on my Virtual Console.
2) It demonstrates functionality and will be the centerpiece for new innovative 4 player gaming. It screams a new 4 Swords game to me.
3) If it ain't broke, don't fix it. I've yet to play a bad Zelda/Mario/Metroid game.
4) They don't really make games for hardcore gamers anymore, they are catering to a family experience. I will give this one to you though because the downside is only 1st party games will be good, just like with the Wii.
5) 3DS has been out for awhile now, why bring that up here? They put 3D on a handheld without the glasses. That's incredible.
6) Fair enough, some like 3D remakes, some don't. If I had money to buy a 3DS I would be more excited about this and Ocarina of Time 3D.
7) Yeah I agree with that too. Seeing how they cater more to the immediate living room experience I am guessing they won't improve this, but I do hope I'm wrong.
Overall there is much to be excited about...but we haven't heard price yet.
EDIT: I'm not saying this to be argumentative, rather my attempt is to be objective and hopefully counter-point some of those with a different perspective. Although I will be the first to admit there is definitely some fanboy in me so I have no problem admitting bias.