Guitar Hero 3? Rock Band?

[Killa]

Which do you think is better?

 

[imported_Hostile]

It depends, are you more interested in playing guitar? If so then GH3 all the way. If you have a lot of friends and want to play as a band obviously go for rock band. But rock band by yourself isn't going to be that fun.

 

[Sir Leeroy]

i say GH3, i love that game

 

[chemically_dependent]

gah, I hate both. I would much rather just play my actual guitar. The drums on rock band sound so annoying.

 

[RaiN]

I enjoy rock band very much

 

[EDITThor]

[quote1197751511=Chemical]
gah, I hate both. I would much rather just play my actual guitar. The drums on rock band sound so annoying.
[/quote1197751511]


Quoted for Truth.

 

[imported_Lawliet]

Guitar Hero 3 is fun for both single players, or multiple. Rockband is only good when you have 4 people around..so GH3 for me.

 

[Deathscythe]

Guitar hero is good if you just want to play the guitar part

For Rock Band i'd get it for the Drums

 

[SogeKing]

I like both of them ^^

 

[Squid56]

RockBand. Where do you think Nuedar and I've been the last 3 weeks?

 

[Deathscythe]

if anyone wants to see my rocking out with guitar hero ill record me playing a song lol

 

[i have no life [DAM]]

i'd saw guitar hero. even though i'm really bad at it i think its less hassle than rock band with the whole giant box to unload and stuff.

 

[Cordl3ssPen]

Party Play: Rock Band
Single Play: GH 3

There is an article somewhere I read that GH3 rocks harder than Rock Band, so if you want to have a challenge, go for GH3.

 

[Weeksaus]

Well i like guitar hero 3 bcuz it seems more challenging than rock band, but i like the drums on rock band ,so i guess both for me

 

[NeOfito]

Guitar Hero 3 all the way! IMO it's more challenging than Rock Band.

 

[jniscool]

Guitar Hero 3 ive already beaten on the Hard setting. My conclusion......Its Awesome.
Ive played Rock Band. My Conclusion.....BLAH. Unless you have 4 people than thats the only way your going to enjoy it to its fullest potential.
Guitar Hero 3 has over 70 different songs plus there are a couple dozen to download off of XBOX Live or off the internet for all you people who want to play it on PC.

 

[RaiN]

I'll buy guitar hero when they decide to let their guitar work with rock band.

 

[Volcom]

just get both

 

[MorbidEwok]

Rock band all the way!

 

[El Jeffe X]

I have to agree with Volcom, get both. I'm an avid GH player, though I don't play as much as I did when the first one came out. At one point, I could play "More Than a Feeling" on Expert without looking at the screen. As far as playing the "guitar", GH wins easily. Rock Band may have a couple of songs that GH3 doesn't, but GH3 has songs that are more interesting for the guitar, a better guitar controller, and some crazy songs near the end.

Having said that, Rock Band is the better game. It may not beat GH3 when it comes to the guitar, but that's it. It has both drums and vocals, giving you three instruments you can play when going solo. It has some great songs, also, some of which are better for drums or vocals, so yeah, they're not as guitar intensive as GH3 songs. And once you do get the band going, with a full set of four people, it is awesome. My friends and I used the character creator to make ourselves up, so we get to see ourselves on all the album covers and playing at the shows. It's a blast.

As a party game, Rock Band wins. As a drum game or karoake game, Rock Band wins. As a guitar game, Guitar Hero 3 wins. Overall, the edge goes to Rock Band.