Why these slogans don't work:
Consoles are for wimps! / Frag me? NO, Frag you!
The problem I see with these is that they sound too confrontational, if someone came to the server and said:
-Hey guys I just bought a PS3
and someone replied -Consoles are for wimps!
we would probably tell that person to be nice to his fellow gamers to prevent any problems.
Dominations R Us!
Although I like this one a lot, sounds too TF2 and we have other divisions with no use for the "domination" part, and then what happens when TF2 becomes obsolete.
Pwning is our business!
This one is simple, it is understood by gamers and all but lacks the punch, you know...
------------
If I had to vote I would choose "Dominations R Us", but our slogan has to reflect our community, our philosophy and style.
I am terrible with words but we have talent here at eGO, I am sure someone will come up with something nice.
Note: This is not a rant, it is constructive criticism.