Rate the above users signature!!!*****

[Abizaga]

3/10
and
1/10
The first one is too plain, and the second hurts my eyes, the red is too vibrant. and done in paint >.>

7/10.
Funny how the second one is supposed to be funny.....

 

[arnarbatman]

i think your new to photoshop, so im gonna give it a 7.
this is way better then when i started making something .
but keep on and keep getting better

 

[Ph?bus]

8.5/10
I like it, but the pattern imo should be under the render.
but its still good.

 

[D-Tektive]

5/10 for that humongous space that is left empty for no apparent reason...
-1 for small pixelated character (enlarge it)
-2 for making some of the binary code flushed by the white gloves
-1 for giving a way low score on a "funny paint" sig
-1 for not thinking the person wanted the "TV-Scan" look

happy grading!

 

[phalanx]

9/10 on both.

Lets not bash each other on here guys.
Lets be constructive in our critiques.

 

[D-Tektive]

9/10 on both.

Lets not bash each other on here guys.
Lets be constructive in our critiques.

Yessir *salute*

10/10 for having the main protagonist of Gundam Wing with a suitable background

 

[Ph?bus]

8/10 for both
for the first one the flow seems a bit.. off
and the second one lacks color. I know its probably supposed to be like that, but its not my style.
but they're still good

 

[Byakuya]

Not bad, I kinda like it. Nice color use. Wonder use of link , dispite what other may think its placement it unique and well within the 2/3rds rule. The white dots tho, dont go with the flow of the sig.

8.5/10

 

[Ph?bus]

9.5/10
its not my style,
but it is a very well done sig.

 

[[R]eMix]

7/10. Very small

 

[Ph?bus]

7/10 for both
Both are quite plain, and the render for Sam Fisher is quite fuzzy around the edge.

 

[Ruthless]

i like this 9/10 good effects nice work on the txt also

 

[Byakuya]

<3 cute! Nice disign, the only reason this sig isnt getting a 10/10 is b.c shes not quite balanced, shes needs to be over to the left a wee bit more. But its still aswome, nice work.
9.3/10

 

[Iceman {Ky}]

7.5/10

 

[Ph?bus]

8/10

 

[[dUsTy] SPiDeR-PiG]

3/10 Messy, pattern doesn't work too well. The compo is ok, but the render could be move up . Could use some flow as well.

Edit: Mine enlarged:

 

[Ph?bus]

5/10
Lacks color,
There is no distinguishable flow,
too much effects around the render,
but it has good lighting.

 

[Kevimaster]

5/10, never really like the color green much, plus is a bit too small :/ though it looks cool :thumbup1:

 

[Ruthless]

7/10

rate my redo

 

[phalanx]

9.5/10 still lookin' good