M
Matz
Prior to the recent changes made on this ruling, it was implied amongst administrators that sufficient time given for prisoners to comply to warden commands was three seconds. If we allow each CT/Guard to depict what would be classified as reasonable time for prisoners to follow or carry out these commands, it would be inconsistent and potentially cause issues. As an administrator(s), we try to stay
consistent to avoid confusion between player(s) on the server.
-CtrlAltDelicious
I get you're trying to be consistent, and I'm glad we can see the end of this implied rule stuff. It's good we're transitioning to a fully written down rulebook.
However, the 3 second rule creates inconsistency. No one is following this rule. If you ran at a CT for 3 seconds after the warden is killed, you'd knife them every time. If you ran at CT in the time it takes for there to be a new warden, plus the orders to be given, plus 3 seconds, the round would be over every time. If you ran at any CT during a freeday and waited for 3 seconds after his command to stop, he'd already be dead. These situations don't occur because people don't follow this implied rule everytime, and if we do now enforce it, there will be inconstancy and imbalance.
Players and admins already use their judgement of what is reasonable. As I said, there is no way to judge 3 seconds in-game, no admin is looking at the clock to count seconds. Admins would be expected to make a judgement here, which would be way more inconsistent than the rule I propose.
Further, when someone is typing, there is no rule on how long they have, so admins are making a judgement on this too.
Judgements are more consistent because they take into account context and don't rely on arbitrary times and rules with loopholes. It's used for legal courts, and indeed, many eGO rules, because it's an effective and consistent way to administrate.
The rule should be as follows:
As a prisoner, you are rebelling if you…
do not follow orders given by the warden and guards within a reasonable time.
As a guard, you must…
give prisoners a reasonable time for typing, unless it's delaying the round.